Plumbing Repair vs. Plumbing Replacement: Which Option is Better?


Apparently, choosing between repair and replacement is a decision you will have to make at some point in life.So, make sure you make the right choice because the decision you make can affect you financially and your family’s comfort.

Plumbing Repair

Plumbing repair involves fixing damaged pipes to ensure you get a reliable supply of water. One technique involved with plumbing repairs is trenchless technology that uses a specialized camera to inspect water lines. This inspection helps to identify the magnitude of the plumbing problem and its exact location. Once your plumber Calgary assesses the damage, they will start working on the repairs.

When to Repair

If you have a minor leak, call a plumber to help you repair the problem. In most cases, plumbers fix the problem using methods, like cured-in-place-piping. The method involves using an epoxy lining to the pipe’s interior. Usually, this lining installs new leak resistant pipes to save homeowners from issues later in the future. Also, if a tree root infiltrates your plumbing lines, contact an expert to correct the problem. The expert will send pressurized water to the pipes to clear obstructions.


  • Saves times
  • Preserves original piping
  • Environmentally friendly
  • Saves money


  • Temporary fixes
  • Labor intensive
  • Limited lifespan
  • Hidden damage

Plumbing Replacement

This involves getting rid of damaged or old pipes and replacing them with new ones. Experts recommend this option when you have outdated pipes or performing significant home renovations. Although plumbing replacement is more costly and extensive, it gives your system a new start, eliminating many risks in the future.

When to Replace

Not all leaks will be reasonable to repair. At times, a tree root may badly damage your water line, and it will be far much better to replace the system instead. Another instance that you will need plumbing replacement is when you constantly repair your water lines and faucets. If it costs a lot to repair the damage, use that money to have a replacement.


  • Better efficiency
  • Longevity
  • Improved home value
  • Better performance


  • Disruption of everyday activities
  • Invasive process
  • Higher cost
  • Environmental impact

Warning Signs for both Plumbing Repair and Replacement

Occasional clogged drains or leaky pipes are common issues that many households experience. Usually, routine repairs help to resolve underlying issues. They offer homeowners a better option to save cash for years. Unfortunately, your plumbing system won’t last forever. You will eventually need to replace them. To make the right decision, you will have to consider the following factors:

1. Age of the System

If your plumbing system is still new, repairs will be a viable option. But if they old and outdated, you will have to replace the entire system.

2. Type of Material

Materials, like copper last longer than others. If you home has ductile iron or lead pipes, then replacing them will be a good option.

3.  Magnitude of the Damage

For minor damages, like water line leaks, opt for repairs. However, if you are dealing with more severe issues, such as breaks or cracks, replacement will be necessary.

Dealing with plumbing issues has never been easy. This is true especially when you have to choose between pipe replacements and repairs. Both options have theirs pros, and are important under unique circumstances. But your final decision narrows down to factors, like cost, material type, age, and extend of the plumbing problem.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *